The dreaded “second album syndrome”, additionally also known as the sophomore droop, is a standard pattern whereby an artist launches to fame and fortune with a stellar debut album after which suffers a nosedive both commercially or critically upon the discharge of their second file. What’s attention-grabbing to notice, is that the phenomenon seems rifer within the modern-day than it was in say the Sixties and ‘70s.
As you’ve began studying, you could have in all probability begun wracking your brains for some examples. I offers you a number of to think about. The artist that first involves thoughts for me is The Stone Roses, who adopted their seminal 1989 debut album with The Second Coming. The album was deemed by critics and lots of followers as a failure relative to their first LP regardless of some admittedly nice moments. One other instance is Franz Ferdinand: the Scottish indie group got here out of the traps triumphantly with their eponymous debut album which was laden with excessive power rock classics like ‘Take Me Out’ and ‘Darkish Of The Matinée’. The group adopted it up swiftly with 2005’s You May Have It So A lot Higher and this, by the way, gave the impression to be the sentiment of critics and customers on the time.
Franz Ferdinand’s second album wasn’t a foul observe up, however the difficulty right here lay with the timing of launch and the dearth of development. Some bands handle to seek out their area of interest of their first album and plug away at it for a number of data with no important dip in business and important engagement. Nevertheless, that is uncommon, and Franz Ferdinand hit us with one other dose of one thing similar to the primary album only a yr later, not permitting their viewers the time to totally digest and excrete the primary triumphant dose.
This is only one of some the explanation why a second album can carry out badly following its launch. Typically it’s a mixture of a number of components. Take The Strokes’ 2001 landmark debut album, Is This It, for example. The album was adopted up with 2003’s Room On Hearth which confirmed little or no inventive or technical development from the debut. However The Strokes have been following an album that was extensively deemed one of the profitable fashionable rock LPs, an instantaneous traditional. How on earth have been they purported to prime it?
When following a profitable album, artists have a selection. Do they hedge their bets and launch a bit extra of the identical? Refraining from pushing too many boundaries in a bid to maintain their loyal viewers on aspect. It is a good possibility, however you threat the critics writing scathing evaluations about not being daring or creatively authentic as on the primary album.
The opposite possibility could be to create one thing that covers new floor. Typically bands could have a better funds following a profitable debut and so second albums can come as a extra refined and textured work. Sadly, this can also spell catastrophe. Loyal followers who loved watching an artist of their formative gigs in grassroots venues in a small hometown will now say that the artist in query “bought out”.
So, does the issue lie with us, the buyer? Fairly presumably. There does seem like a way of tribalism in music that may assist deliver a band to prominence however may also injury their repute after they turn into world-renowned. Within the childhood, a band would possibly garner a loyal native fanbase who would be the first to disown them after they conquer the world. For instance, the Arctic Monkeys seem to have misplaced reference to their Sheffield followers an increasing number of with every new album since 2006; their ever-evolving sound now bears little or no resemblance to the uncooked native power that introduced them fame within the first place. Arctic Monkeys didn’t fall sufferer to second album syndrome, however their path proves that it’s unimaginable to maintain everybody completely happy following an increase to fame.
If we now forged our minds again to the Sixties and think about bands of the British invasion period, reminiscent of The Rolling Stones and The Beatles. These bands seemingly averted album syndrome due to the best way they have been launched to the charts and the time they have been fortunate sufficient to exist in. They have been round at a time when labels tended to develop and nurture promising up and coming sounds with a fantastic deal extra endurance and supervision than is commonly seen within the fashionable age. The bands have been allowed to dip a toe earlier than full submersion and so for his or her first albums, they may stick primarily to rhythm and blues covers earlier than rising into their creativity over subsequent data.
The sobering reality of the matter is that second album syndrome is incurable and near-impossible to anticipate. The rationale we see this pattern is as a result of we hardly ever hear of the artists who flop on their first album. To clarify the apparent, the album by no means launched them into wider consciousness and due to this fact they slip beneath the radar. Sadly, particularly within the modern-day, artists don’t get two bites of the cherry. Labels aren’t within the enterprise of nurturing failing artists like they might have been prior to now and so it’s uncommon that these with a failed first album will come again with a second, and in the event that they do, the advertising funds could be minimal.
To analogise my level, think about the primary album as the primary flip of a coin, heads is unbridled success, tails is failure and a return to day jobs. If you happen to flip heads on the primary, everyone can see your success. You flip once more in your second album and also you stand a 50% likelihood of “second album syndrome”. After all, I perceive that these aren’t the percentages within the analogous state of affairs. As an outsider, all you possibly can see is a big group of people that flipped heads the primary time and what seems to be a “pattern” of many of those bowing out with tails on the second album.
So, to keep away from second album syndrome, I counsel you get a time machine, journey again to the Sixties and begin off sluggish with a blues cowl group. Failing that, which you’ll, you have to to handle your expectations and perceive that it’s out of your arms. All you are able to do is give your self the very best likelihood by releasing the music that you simply’re actually keen about. In case your native following is expensive to you, then it’s in all probability clever to not promote out to fame and fortune. In case your aim is business acclaim, then observe the recommendation of your label. Lastly, in case your aim is vital acclaim, don’t be afraid to push the boundaries into the avant-garde; it might not reap the identical monetary rewards as your first album, however you would possibly simply be heralded as one of the necessary artists of your time in years to return.
Comply with Far Out Journal throughout our social channels, on Fb, Twitter and Instagram.